Van Gogh was fascinated in Japan:
Vincent Van Gogh's fascination for Japan
Van Gogh Museum - Van Gogh & Japan - trailer | Facebook
But it wasn't just Vincent:
Fascination Japan. Monet · Van Gogh · Klimt on Vimeo
Today we are also fascinated:
[See at 13:30 and 24:00]
BBC Radio 4 - Moving Pictures, Kimono
On the BBC:
BBC - Japan
BBC Four - The Art of Japanese Life, Series 1, Cities, The 'floating world' of Edo
And from Kazuo Ishiguru:
An Artist of the Floating World - Wikipedia
This is modern Japan:
BBC Four - Arena, Kusama: Infinity
BBC Four - Ryan Gander: The Idea of Japan
We need to be careful, though:
Jay Doubleyou: othering
.
.
.
Saturday, 31 August 2019
we are much more than problem-solvers
Problem-solving is a very useful skill:
Jay Doubleyou: scenarios for problem solving
Jay Doubleyou: tinkering school
"The number one skill that employers are seeking today and in the future is complex problem solving":
How to Teach Kids Better Problem Solving | Michael Arnold | TEDxGreenville - YouTube
However:
Jay Doubleyou: Search results for prussian
prussian education system problem solving - Google Search
2017:
What are some alternatives to the Prussian educational system? - Quora
wow:
Mythology that keeps the archaic school system alive - supermemo.guru
SuperMemo Guru - supermemo.guru
prussian education system "problem solving" - Google Search
2016:
No grammar schools, lots of play: the secrets of Europe’s top education system | Education | The Guardian
prussian education system "problem solving" managerial - Google Search
nov 2018:
this is a prussian education system hateblog | Thing of Things
2019:
School is less of an "education" system and more of a "get used to doing shit you don't have any interest in without question for the rest of your life" system. : Showerthoughts
.
.
.
Jay Doubleyou: scenarios for problem solving
Jay Doubleyou: tinkering school
"The number one skill that employers are seeking today and in the future is complex problem solving":
How to Teach Kids Better Problem Solving | Michael Arnold | TEDxGreenville - YouTube
However:
Jay Doubleyou: Search results for prussian
prussian education system problem solving - Google Search
2017:
What are some alternatives to the Prussian educational system? - Quora
wow:
Mythology that keeps the archaic school system alive - supermemo.guru
SuperMemo Guru - supermemo.guru
prussian education system "problem solving" - Google Search
2016:
No grammar schools, lots of play: the secrets of Europe’s top education system | Education | The Guardian
prussian education system "problem solving" managerial - Google Search
nov 2018:
this is a prussian education system hateblog | Thing of Things
2019:
School is less of an "education" system and more of a "get used to doing shit you don't have any interest in without question for the rest of your life" system. : Showerthoughts
.
.
.
grammar workshop
GRAMMAR INTRO:
What is 'grammar'?
Grammar - Wikipedia
What is Grammar? | Grammar | EnglishClub
Michael Lewis' book 'The Verb' provides an excellent overview of English grammar - how to understand it, to teach it, to learn it:
The English Verb by Michael Lewis: Book Review - YouTube
Amazon.com: The English Verb: An Exploration of Structure and Meaning (9780906717400): Michael Lewis: Books
For one thing, we teach each tense as if it were a series of uses, each unconnected to each other, and then a series of exceptions to each of these uses. This has the effect of just confusing and discouraging our students.
As Michael Lewis says on page 13:
Most student grammars, and textbook syllabuses, are based on a catalogue approach to grammar. Different points are covered one by one in separate paragraphs or units. Each paragraph is independent of the others. There are two difficulties which result from this.
Random Book and Movie Reviews: The English Verb by Michael Lewis
SOME AND ANY:
Michael Lewis illustrates this at the beginning with a look at the 'rules' of some and any.
This dictionary simply gives a definition:
SOME | meaning in the Cambridge English Dictionary
ANY | meaning in the Cambridge English Dictionary
And it's a problem when it comes to translation - for example:
some | translate English to German: Cambridge Dictionary
any | translate English to German: Cambridge Dictionary
some | translate English to Spanish: Cambridge Dictionary
any | translate English to Spanish: Cambridge Dictionary
some pronoun, quantifier | translate English to Polish: Cambridge Dictionary
any pronoun, determiner | translate English to Polish: Cambridge Dictionary
Look at how this English-English dictionary features them and it's all about USE:
some_1 determiner - Definition, pictures, pronunciation and usage notes | Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary at OxfordLearnersDictionaries.com
any_1 determiner - Definition, pictures, pronunciation and usage notes | Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary at OxfordLearnersDictionaries.com
So, which activities would we do to learn 'some' and 'any'?
(1) Some and Any Fruit Game (How To Teach Some and Any) - YouTube
How to use Some and Any | Learn English
PREPOSITIONS AND ARTICLES:
It's all about chunks:
Following the pattern that most course books take, i.e., dealing with prepositions in manageable chunks, is not a bad way to go. Teaching prepositions of time, place and movement, for instance, at different times, will enable learners to build up their knowledge of prepositions slowly and steadily. Doing so will be much more effective than, say, trying to teach every use of 'in' at the same time.
How to help learners of English understand prepositions | British Council
Sure, we can give students rules to apply, such as; use on with days of the week; in for months and years; at for specific times and holidays, but as native English speakers we do not grow up learning these rules, or even thinking about what preposition to use. Ask an English speaking child, “Where is your mother?” They will know to say at home instead of in home or on home. This is not instinctive; it has been acquired through hearing and mimicking, which is not the same way that students learn the language. Children learn languages in chunks and phrases so English learners should do the same.
Learn prepositions easily
You can also say it's all about phrases:
Prepositional phrases (video) | Khan Academy
Or collocation:
Grammar and vocabulary: teaching students collocations | Onestopenglish
Fun classroom practice of collocations - UsingEnglish.com
DRILLING:
From 5 minutes into this BBC radio programme, we can see 'chunking' at work:
The Documentary - The Superlinguists - How to learn a language - BBC Sounds
Jay Doubleyou: how to learn a language from 'superlinguists'
It's the music which helps us to remember 'chunks', or complete phrases:
Jazz chants | Onestopenglish
For example:
> I've always cooked my pasta with the lid on
> She's never played the cello with her father
> They've normally done the washing by bed time
PERFECT ASPECT:
It's all very confusing:
timeline present perfect - Google Search
Michael Lewis shows it's about finding a defining principle:
Each verb tense represents a different subjective view of time, and all of the different uses of a particular verb tense can be connected back to this same view.
For example, the present perfect can be used in a number of different situations, as listed above, but all the usages have a unifying characteristic—each use indicates that the speaker is looking back at a past event from the perspective of the present.
Once this is understood, the series of “rules” which we English teachers give about the present perfect are not really “rules”, but simply hints to help the student identify in which situations the present perfect is likely to be used.
Random Book and Movie Reviews: The English Verb by Michael Lewis
You can see it being used here:
Jay Doubleyou: goldilocks and the three bears > a story to tell the difference between present perfect simple and continuous
And here:
Jay Doubleyou: present perfect for experiences
SENTENCE STRUCTURE:
Rinvolucri's Grammar Games is full of fun ways to deal with syntax:
Grammar Games : Mario Rinvolucri : 9780521277730
Grammar Games, Mario Rinvolucri
And:
More Grammar Games | Mario Rinvolucri and Paul Davis
4549394-English-Teaching-ResourcesMore-Grammar-Games.pdf
Whereas this is a little boring but useful:
(1) Learn English Grammar: The Sentence - YouTube
It's actually rather difficult:
Jay Doubleyou: word order
INDUCTIVE OR DEDUCTIVE:
A deductive approach involves the learners being given a general rule, which is then applied to specific language examples and honed through practice exercises. An inductive approach involves the learners detecting, or noticing, patterns and working out a 'rule' for themselves before they practise the language
Inductive and deductive grammar teaching: what is it, and does it work? - Oxford University Press
(1) How to Teach an Inductive Learning Lesson - YouTube
NOTICING:
Finally, we just need to see how it works:
How to get the most out of English texts | Antimoon
Is “pause and think” worth it? « The Antimoon Blog
.
.
.
What is 'grammar'?
Grammar - Wikipedia
What is Grammar? | Grammar | EnglishClub
Michael Lewis' book 'The Verb' provides an excellent overview of English grammar - how to understand it, to teach it, to learn it:
The English Verb by Michael Lewis: Book Review - YouTube
Amazon.com: The English Verb: An Exploration of Structure and Meaning (9780906717400): Michael Lewis: Books
Basically, Michael Lewis says that we English teachers have been teaching the verb tenses all wrong.
For one thing, we teach each tense as if it were a series of uses, each unconnected to each other, and then a series of exceptions to each of these uses. This has the effect of just confusing and discouraging our students.
As Michael Lewis says on page 13:
Most student grammars, and textbook syllabuses, are based on a catalogue approach to grammar. Different points are covered one by one in separate paragraphs or units. Each paragraph is independent of the others. There are two difficulties which result from this.
Firstly, students are given the impression that they are attempting an impossible task; as soon as they have finished one paragraph, or one use of a verb form, they are presented with another, and another, and another… . Rarely, if ever, do they see the parts they are learning as coming together to form a coherent whole. Not surprisingly, such a catalogue approach, giving an impression of impossibility, de-motivates students.
The second problem is that each paragraph is, in a way, an exception to the previous paragraph. Students may, for example, learn that the present continuous is used for an action going on at the moment of speaking (this is a dangerous half truth…), and then they learn that the present continuous can also be used for the future. Nobody take times to explain that there is a reason for this, and that indeed the two uses are fundamentally the same….
This “catalogue and exceptions” approach must depress students. Instead of encouraging a feeling of progress as they learn more language, it gives them a feeling that the task is becoming more and more impossible.
Random Book and Movie Reviews: The English Verb by Michael Lewis
SOME AND ANY:
Michael Lewis illustrates this at the beginning with a look at the 'rules' of some and any.
This dictionary simply gives a definition:
SOME | meaning in the Cambridge English Dictionary
ANY | meaning in the Cambridge English Dictionary
And it's a problem when it comes to translation - for example:
some | translate English to German: Cambridge Dictionary
any | translate English to German: Cambridge Dictionary
some | translate English to Spanish: Cambridge Dictionary
any | translate English to Spanish: Cambridge Dictionary
some pronoun, quantifier | translate English to Polish: Cambridge Dictionary
any pronoun, determiner | translate English to Polish: Cambridge Dictionary
Look at how this English-English dictionary features them and it's all about USE:
some_1 determiner - Definition, pictures, pronunciation and usage notes | Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary at OxfordLearnersDictionaries.com
any_1 determiner - Definition, pictures, pronunciation and usage notes | Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary at OxfordLearnersDictionaries.com
So, which activities would we do to learn 'some' and 'any'?
(1) Some and Any Fruit Game (How To Teach Some and Any) - YouTube
How to use Some and Any | Learn English
PREPOSITIONS AND ARTICLES:
It's all about chunks:
Following the pattern that most course books take, i.e., dealing with prepositions in manageable chunks, is not a bad way to go. Teaching prepositions of time, place and movement, for instance, at different times, will enable learners to build up their knowledge of prepositions slowly and steadily. Doing so will be much more effective than, say, trying to teach every use of 'in' at the same time.
How to help learners of English understand prepositions | British Council
Sure, we can give students rules to apply, such as; use on with days of the week; in for months and years; at for specific times and holidays, but as native English speakers we do not grow up learning these rules, or even thinking about what preposition to use. Ask an English speaking child, “Where is your mother?” They will know to say at home instead of in home or on home. This is not instinctive; it has been acquired through hearing and mimicking, which is not the same way that students learn the language. Children learn languages in chunks and phrases so English learners should do the same.
Learn prepositions easily
You can also say it's all about phrases:
Prepositional phrases (video) | Khan Academy
Or collocation:
Grammar and vocabulary: teaching students collocations | Onestopenglish
Fun classroom practice of collocations - UsingEnglish.com
DRILLING:
From 5 minutes into this BBC radio programme, we can see 'chunking' at work:
The Documentary - The Superlinguists - How to learn a language - BBC Sounds
Jay Doubleyou: how to learn a language from 'superlinguists'
It's the music which helps us to remember 'chunks', or complete phrases:
Jazz chants | Onestopenglish
For example:
> I've always cooked my pasta with the lid on
> She's never played the cello with her father
> They've normally done the washing by bed time
PERFECT ASPECT:
It's all very confusing:
timeline present perfect - Google Search
Michael Lewis shows it's about finding a defining principle:
Each verb tense represents a different subjective view of time, and all of the different uses of a particular verb tense can be connected back to this same view.
For example, the present perfect can be used in a number of different situations, as listed above, but all the usages have a unifying characteristic—each use indicates that the speaker is looking back at a past event from the perspective of the present.
Once this is understood, the series of “rules” which we English teachers give about the present perfect are not really “rules”, but simply hints to help the student identify in which situations the present perfect is likely to be used.
Random Book and Movie Reviews: The English Verb by Michael Lewis
You can see it being used here:
Jay Doubleyou: goldilocks and the three bears > a story to tell the difference between present perfect simple and continuous
And here:
Jay Doubleyou: present perfect for experiences
SENTENCE STRUCTURE:
Rinvolucri's Grammar Games is full of fun ways to deal with syntax:
Grammar Games : Mario Rinvolucri : 9780521277730
Grammar Games, Mario Rinvolucri
And:
More Grammar Games | Mario Rinvolucri and Paul Davis
4549394-English-Teaching-ResourcesMore-Grammar-Games.pdf
Whereas this is a little boring but useful:
(1) Learn English Grammar: The Sentence - YouTube
It's actually rather difficult:
Jay Doubleyou: word order
INDUCTIVE OR DEDUCTIVE:
A deductive approach involves the learners being given a general rule, which is then applied to specific language examples and honed through practice exercises. An inductive approach involves the learners detecting, or noticing, patterns and working out a 'rule' for themselves before they practise the language
Inductive and deductive grammar teaching: what is it, and does it work? - Oxford University Press
(1) How to Teach an Inductive Learning Lesson - YouTube
NOTICING:
Finally, we just need to see how it works:
How to get the most out of English texts | Antimoon
Is “pause and think” worth it? « The Antimoon Blog
.
.
.
Monday, 19 August 2019
heuristics in language learning
Learners can learn for themselves:
Jay Doubleyou: tinkering school
Where the language is the tool:
Jay Doubleyou: task-based learning
And where learning is self-guided:
Jay Doubleyou: the trivium method of critical thinking and creative problem solving
Let's have a look at 'heuristics':
A heuristic technique (/hjʊəˈrɪstɪk/; Ancient Greek: εὑρίσκω, "find" or "discover"), often called simply a heuristic, is any approach to problem solving or self-discovery that employs a practical method, not guaranteed to be optimal, perfect, or rational, but instead sufficient for reaching an immediate goal. Where finding an optimal solution is impossible or impractical, heuristic methods can be used to speed up the process of finding a satisfactory solution. Heuristics can be mental shortcuts that ease the cognitive load of making a decision.[1]:94Examples that employ heuristics include using a rule of thumb, an educated guess, an intuitive judgment, a guesstimate, profiling, or common sense.
Jay Doubleyou: tinkering school
Where the language is the tool:
Jay Doubleyou: task-based learning
And where learning is self-guided:
Jay Doubleyou: the trivium method of critical thinking and creative problem solving
Let's have a look at 'heuristics':
A heuristic technique (/hjʊəˈrɪstɪk/; Ancient Greek: εὑρίσκω, "find" or "discover"), often called simply a heuristic, is any approach to problem solving or self-discovery that employs a practical method, not guaranteed to be optimal, perfect, or rational, but instead sufficient for reaching an immediate goal. Where finding an optimal solution is impossible or impractical, heuristic methods can be used to speed up the process of finding a satisfactory solution. Heuristics can be mental shortcuts that ease the cognitive load of making a decision.[1]:94Examples that employ heuristics include using a rule of thumb, an educated guess, an intuitive judgment, a guesstimate, profiling, or common sense.
This might help:
(1) What Are Heuristics? - YouTube
Heuristics are definitely used when learning:
The Heuristic Method of Learning
Heuristic method
The Montessori Method: A Heuristic Approach to Learning - NAMC Montessori Teacher Training Blog
Another example:
Maximizing language learning by activating intuitive heuristics Dr. Ilknur Oded. - ppt download
Here's a more detailed look at how it works when learning a language:
Heuristics are definitely used when learning:
The Heuristic Method of Learning
Heuristic method
The Montessori Method: A Heuristic Approach to Learning - NAMC Montessori Teacher Training Blog
Another example:
Maximizing language learning by activating intuitive heuristics Dr. Ilknur Oded. - ppt download
Here's a more detailed look at how it works when learning a language:
Intuitive Heuristics
Heuristics refer to:
the process of self-discovery on the part of the learner
“a method of teaching allowing the students to learn by discovering things by
themselves and learning from their own experiences rather than by telling them
things”
Cambridge International Dictionary of English
How to create a rich linguistic environment in the classroom so that learners can activate their intuitive heuristics and discover the linguistic system by themselves?
Relationship to Language Awareness
1. Language awareness can be increased by attempting to discover the rules and patterns of the linguistic system
Intuitive Heuristics and Grammar
Language is systematic and rule-governed. The rule that teachers and learners are familiar with is grammar. Therefore, macro-strategy of activating intuitive heuristics related to the teaching of L2 grammar is necessary. Although experts still debate whether inductive methods is more preferable, experts (Chomsky, 1970:108; Sweet, 1899:128; Jesperson, 1904) agree that learner self-discovery is vital.
Sample 1: Deductive Grammar Teaching
1) Teacher starts with a rule from a grammar textbook.
Deductive Teaching and Intuitive Heuristics
In a usual deductive method of teaching grammar, the teacher presents learners with a set of grammatical rules, give explicit explanations of those rules, and then provide opportunities for learners to practice them. After enough practice, the learners are expected to use those rules in their speech and writing.The suitability of a deductive method of grammar teaching has been doubted by theoretical as well as applied linguists. Chomsky (1970) implies is that the linguistic system of any language is so complex that even theoretical linguists who spend their lives have not been able to satisfactorily describe, explain, and understand it. Therefore, it is too much to expect either the language teacher or the language learner to do so...
(PDF) English Instruction Issues Intuitive Heuristics - A summary | Dera Estuarso - Academia.edu
.
.
.
Heuristics refer to:
the process of self-discovery on the part of the learner
“a method of teaching allowing the students to learn by discovering things by
themselves and learning from their own experiences rather than by telling them
things”
Cambridge International Dictionary of English
Intuitive heuristics is one’s capacity to discover the linguistic system
Problem in Teaching & Learning
Problem in Teaching & Learning
How to create a rich linguistic environment in the classroom so that learners can activate their intuitive heuristics and discover the linguistic system by themselves?
Relationship to Language Awareness
1. Language awareness can be increased by attempting to discover the rules and patterns of the linguistic system
2.Intuitive heuristics can be enhanced by increasing language awareness.
Intuitive Heuristics and Grammar
Language is systematic and rule-governed. The rule that teachers and learners are familiar with is grammar. Therefore, macro-strategy of activating intuitive heuristics related to the teaching of L2 grammar is necessary. Although experts still debate whether inductive methods is more preferable, experts (Chomsky, 1970:108; Sweet, 1899:128; Jesperson, 1904) agree that learner self-discovery is vital.
To help learners discover powerful patterns underlying the linguistic system teachers can use
(1) grammaticization in which the learner is constantly engaged in “reanalysing data,reformulating
hypotheses, recasting generalizations, etc.” including making the connection between propositional content and syntactic forms within a communicative context and
hypotheses, recasting generalizations, etc.” including making the connection between propositional content and syntactic forms within a communicative context and
(2)grammaring which involves learners’ focusing more on
reasoning than on rules.
reasoning than on rules.
Grammar in Action
Sample 1: Deductive Grammar Teaching
1) Teacher starts with a rule from a grammar textbook.
2) Learners are asked to identify some samples of sentences in the target language and match the rules.
3) Learning is teacher centered, minimum interaction and negotiation.
4) Teacher’s enthusiasm to deal with the grammatical rule sacrifices an opportunity to create a linguistic environment necessary to activate the learners’ intuitive heuristics.
Sample 2. Inductive Grammar Teaching
1) Teacher starts with a picture.
4) Teacher’s enthusiasm to deal with the grammatical rule sacrifices an opportunity to create a linguistic environment necessary to activate the learners’ intuitive heuristics.
Sample 2. Inductive Grammar Teaching
1) Teacher starts with a picture.
2) Teacher asks learners to come up with possible sentences using what-if questions.
3) Teacher guides learners with more possibilities providing a word to construct different new sentences.
4) Learners produced many different sentences.
5) Teachers take students attention to the form of the sentences they produced and discuss the grammar rules of each sentence.
6) Teacher involves the learners in a meaningful conversational exchange.
Conclusion:
Because teacher in Sample 2 creates learning opportunities, promotes interaction in class, and fosters general language awareness, in spite of the explicitness, activation of the intuitive heuristics is successful.
Deductive Teaching and Intuitive Heuristics
In a usual deductive method of teaching grammar, the teacher presents learners with a set of grammatical rules, give explicit explanations of those rules, and then provide opportunities for learners to practice them. After enough practice, the learners are expected to use those rules in their speech and writing.The suitability of a deductive method of grammar teaching has been doubted by theoretical as well as applied linguists. Chomsky (1970) implies is that the linguistic system of any language is so complex that even theoretical linguists who spend their lives have not been able to satisfactorily describe, explain, and understand it. Therefore, it is too much to expect either the language teacher or the language learner to do so...
(PDF) English Instruction Issues Intuitive Heuristics - A summary | Dera Estuarso - Academia.edu
.
.
.
scenarios for problem solving
How to solve a problem:
Jay Doubleyou: questioning and problem-solving
Sometimes it needs a bit of 'lateral thinking':
Lateral Thinking Puzzles - Preconceptions
Lateral Thinking Puzzles
But let's look at what we mean by 'problem solving':
Problem solving (video) | Cognition | Khan Academy
And this is what kids are learning:
(1) Real-World Problem Solving: Finding Solutions Through Projects - YouTube
And what elephants are doing:
Aha! Elephants Can Use Insight to Solve Problems | Science | AAAS
How could we solve this little problem?
Weekend Fun: An Example of Poor Problem Solving – Lean Blog
Here are some more examples:
Example of Problem Solving: Comparing Purchase versus Rent To Own Cost - YouTube
Why Doesn't the Moon Fall to Earth? Exploring Orbits and Gravity - YouTube
What's your problem? The 5 Whys
3.1 Collaborative Problem Solving: An example of a 21st century skill - How to teach and assess Collaborative Problem Solving (CPS) as an example of a C21 skill | Coursera
Chapter 17. Analyzing Community Problems and Solutions | Section 3. Defining and Analyzing the Problem | Main Section | Community Tool Box
In other words, it's helpful to have specific Scenarios for Problem Solving, for example:
ESL BY DESIGN
.
.
.
Jay Doubleyou: questioning and problem-solving
Sometimes it needs a bit of 'lateral thinking':
Lateral Thinking Puzzles - Preconceptions
Lateral Thinking Puzzles
But let's look at what we mean by 'problem solving':
Problem solving (video) | Cognition | Khan Academy
And this is what kids are learning:
(1) Real-World Problem Solving: Finding Solutions Through Projects - YouTube
And what elephants are doing:
Aha! Elephants Can Use Insight to Solve Problems | Science | AAAS
How could we solve this little problem?
Weekend Fun: An Example of Poor Problem Solving – Lean Blog
Here are some more examples:
Example of Problem Solving: Comparing Purchase versus Rent To Own Cost - YouTube
Why Doesn't the Moon Fall to Earth? Exploring Orbits and Gravity - YouTube
What's your problem? The 5 Whys
3.1 Collaborative Problem Solving: An example of a 21st century skill - How to teach and assess Collaborative Problem Solving (CPS) as an example of a C21 skill | Coursera
Chapter 17. Analyzing Community Problems and Solutions | Section 3. Defining and Analyzing the Problem | Main Section | Community Tool Box
In other words, it's helpful to have specific Scenarios for Problem Solving, for example:
ESL BY DESIGN
.
.
.
tinkering school
To tinker:
to make small changes to something, especially in an attempt to repair or improve it:
He spends every weekend tinkering (around) with his car.
I wish the government would stop tinkering with the health service.
TINKER | meaning in the Cambridge English Dictionary
To solve problems by trial and error:
Jay Doubleyou: questioning and problem-solving
Jay Doubleyou: task-based learning
Jay Doubleyou: play and learning
Jay Doubleyou: processes and procedures
Jay Doubleyou: thinking fast and slow
Jay Doubleyou: the trivium method of critical thinking and creative problem solving
Jay Doubleyou: appreciative inquiry is not problem-solving
Jay Doubleyou: critical thinking
There is a school where you can do and do this sort of stuff:
Tinkering School
At Tinkering School there is no set curriculum. There are no tests or evaluations, and collaborators do not teach any particular subject. All learning is student-directed and project-based.
Tinkering School - Wikipedia
Here's a great TED Talk:
A software engineer, Gever Tulley is the co-founder of the Tinkering School, a week-long camp where lucky kids get to play with their very own power tools. He's interested in helping kids learn how to build, solve problems, use new materials and hack old ones for new purposes.
(1) TEDxKids@Brussels - Gever Tulley - Tinkering School - YouTube
And here's a slightly shorter one:
Gever Tulley: Life lessons through tinkering | TED Talk
Also on YouTube:
(1) Gever Tulley teaches life lessons through tinkering - YouTube
With a worksheet here:
Gever Tulley teaches life lessons through tinkering - English ESL Worksheets
Or perhaps you'd rather make up your own worksheet...
Because that's what it's all about:
The Tinkering School operates under three unusual and refreshing assumptions about kids:
(1) They are more capable than they know. By giving them big responsibility, you build competency and self-confidence, while creating lasting memories.
(2) The freedom to fail is essential. “A failure-positive atmosphere allows children to play in the face of adversity.”
(3) It can be done bigger and bolder. There’s no limit to the ambitiousness and awesomeness of the projects that Tulley’s young Tinkerers tackle.
Challenge-based learning builds on the foundation of experiential learning, leans heavily on the wisdom of a long history of progressive education, shares many of the goals of service learning, and the activism of critical pedagogy. The framework is informed by innovative ideas from education, media, technology, entertainment, recreation, the workplace, and society.
I wish the government would stop tinkering with the health service.
TINKER | meaning in the Cambridge English Dictionary
To solve problems by trial and error:
Jay Doubleyou: questioning and problem-solving
Jay Doubleyou: task-based learning
Jay Doubleyou: play and learning
Jay Doubleyou: processes and procedures
Jay Doubleyou: thinking fast and slow
Jay Doubleyou: the trivium method of critical thinking and creative problem solving
Jay Doubleyou: appreciative inquiry is not problem-solving
Jay Doubleyou: critical thinking
There is a school where you can do and do this sort of stuff:
Tinkering School
At Tinkering School there is no set curriculum. There are no tests or evaluations, and collaborators do not teach any particular subject. All learning is student-directed and project-based.
Tinkering School - Wikipedia
Here's a great TED Talk:
A software engineer, Gever Tulley is the co-founder of the Tinkering School, a week-long camp where lucky kids get to play with their very own power tools. He's interested in helping kids learn how to build, solve problems, use new materials and hack old ones for new purposes.
(1) TEDxKids@Brussels - Gever Tulley - Tinkering School - YouTube
And here's a slightly shorter one:
Gever Tulley: Life lessons through tinkering | TED Talk
Also on YouTube:
(1) Gever Tulley teaches life lessons through tinkering - YouTube
With a worksheet here:
Gever Tulley teaches life lessons through tinkering - English ESL Worksheets
Or perhaps you'd rather make up your own worksheet...
Because that's what it's all about:
The Tinkering School operates under three unusual and refreshing assumptions about kids:
(1) They are more capable than they know. By giving them big responsibility, you build competency and self-confidence, while creating lasting memories.
(2) The freedom to fail is essential. “A failure-positive atmosphere allows children to play in the face of adversity.”
(3) It can be done bigger and bolder. There’s no limit to the ambitiousness and awesomeness of the projects that Tulley’s young Tinkerers tackle.
It's connected to this:
Challenge-based learning builds on the foundation of experiential learning, leans heavily on the wisdom of a long history of progressive education, shares many of the goals of service learning, and the activism of critical pedagogy. The framework is informed by innovative ideas from education, media, technology, entertainment, recreation, the workplace, and society.
Sunday, 18 August 2019
krashen and second language learning
Krashen's understanding of how we learn languages is not only very interesting but very helpful - for both learners and teachers:
Jay Doubleyou: theories of language learning and teaching: input
Jay Doubleyou: second language acquisition
Jay Doubleyou: behaviourism >>> krashen... pinker... skinner... chomsky
The Frankfurt International School has some excellent resources:
A guide to learning English - esl.fis
The following has been taken from a piece on Krashen:
An introduction to the work of Stephen Krashen
See also:
Jay Doubleyou: questioning and problem-solving
Jay Doubleyou: task-based learning
Jay Doubleyou: play and learning
Jay Doubleyou: processes and procedures
Jay Doubleyou: thinking fast and slow
Jay Doubleyou: the trivium method of critical thinking and creative problem solving
Jay Doubleyou: appreciative inquiry is not problem-solving
Jay Doubleyou: critical thinking
.
.
.
Jay Doubleyou: theories of language learning and teaching: input
Jay Doubleyou: second language acquisition
Jay Doubleyou: behaviourism >>> krashen... pinker... skinner... chomsky
The Frankfurt International School has some excellent resources:
A guide to learning English - esl.fis
The following has been taken from a piece on Krashen:
An introduction to the work of Stephen Krashen
This page contains an introduction to the work of Stephen Krashen, Emeritus Professor of Linguistics and Education at the University of Southern California. It was written in advance of Dr. Krashen's visit to Frankfurt International School (FIS) in October 2009 to lead the school's two-day professional development.
The page as shown initially contains a brief synopsis of Krashen's work in the fields of second language learning, free voluntary reading, bilingual education, whole language, cognitive development and writing.
Teachers who are interested in further information about the various issues can click [More] at the end of each section.
Second language learning
Krashen believes that there is no fundamental difference between the way we acquire our first language and our subsequent languages. He claims that humans have an innate ability that guides the language learning process. Infants learn their mother tongue simply by listening attentively to spoken language that is (made) meaningful to them. Foreign languages are acquired in the same way.
The claim that humans possess an innate language learning ability stems from Chomsky (1965), who rejected Skinner's (1957) behaviourist theory that language learning is habit formation through stimulus and response. Chomsky called the special inborn language capability the Language Acquisition Device (LAD). From this he developed the theory that all languages share an underlying system named Universal Grammar. The hypothesis that the ability to learn language is innate has been restated more recently by linguist Steven Pinker who claims that this ability is "hard-wired in the genes".
Chomsky and Pinker are nativists. Their theories are opposed by contemporary empiricists such as Sampson (2005), who reiterate Skinner's claim that language develops in response to environmental influences. Other linguists and cognitive scientists, such as O'Grady (2005), agree that humans possess significant innate capabilities. However, they suggest that language learning depends on general cognitive faculties rather than on a specific language acquisition mechanism.
The Acquisition-Learning Hypothesis
There are two ways of developing language ability: by acquisition and by learning. Acquisition is a sub-conscious process, as in the case of a child learning its own language or an adult 'picking up' a second language simply by living and working in a foreign country. Learning is the conscious process of developing a foreign language through language lessons and a focus on the grammatical features of that language.
[More]
The Natural Order Hypothesis
Language is acquired in a predictable order by all learners. This order does not depend on the apparent simplicity or complexity of the grammatical features involved. The natural order of acquisition cannot be influenced by direct teaching of features that the learner is not yet ready to acquire.
[More]
The Monitor Hypothesis
We are able to use what we have learned (in Krashen's sense) about the rules of a language in monitoring (or self-correcting) our language output. Clearly, this is possible in the correction of written work. It is much more difficult when engaging in regular talk.
[More]
The Input Hypothesis
We acquire language in one way only: when we are exposed to input (written or spoken language) that is comprehensible to us. Comprehensible input is the necessary but also sufficient condition for language acquisition to take place. It requires no effort on the part of the learner.
[More]
The Affective Filter Hypothesis
Comprehensible input will not result in language acquisition if that input is filtered out before it can reach the brain's language processing faculties. The filtering may occur because of anxiety, poor self-esteem or low motivation.
[More]
Free voluntary reading
Free voluntary reading (FVR) is the reading of any book (newspaper, magazine or comic) that students have chosen for themselves and is not subject to follow-up work such as comprehension questions or a summary. Krashen (2003) makes the claim that Free voluntary reading 'may be the most powerful educational tool in language education'. It serves to increase literacy and to develop vocabulary.§§
Extensive voluntary reading provides non-native students with large doses of comprehensible input with a low affective filter, and thus is a major factor in their general language acquisition.
More on free voluntary reading
Krashen (2004) expands on his claim in his book The Power of Reading. His own and other's research has led him to the following conclusions:
- Students who read more do better on a wide variety of tests.
- Reading is the most significant factor in the development of vocabulary.
- Reading is the major factor in the development of writing competence.
- Students who read extensively have a greater general knowledge.
- Self-selected reading is extremely enjoyable and probably the most popular means of achieving of what Csikszentmihalyi (1991) calls flow, the psychology of optimal experience.
Here is a useful online summary of Krashen's recent work on FVR.
Whole Language
Krashen is a strong advocate of the whole language approach to the teaching of reading, and has written many articles in support of it. In essence, whole language proponents claim that children learn to read most enjoyably and efficiently by exposure to interesting stories that are made comprehensible to them through pictures and discussions. This is in contrast to structured decoding programmes (usually designated phonics) in which children learn to read by sounding out the various parts of words.
[More]
Comments
The whole language/phonics debate has become politicised and increasingly vitriolic. Constant media reports about falling literacy standards have alarmed parents, many of whom vehemently protest if they consider their child's school to have chosen the wrong approach. The issue is further complicated by the involvement of publishing houses which stand to make large profits if school districts can be persuaded to buy their comprehensive sets of phonics-based materials. Such an entanglement of interests is rarely conducive to making the best pedagogical decisions.
[More]
Cognitive development
Krashen (2003) claims that cognitive development, including the acquisition of concepts and facts, is more likely to occur through problem-solving than through deliberate study. It is a confusion of cause and effect to teach facts and thinking skills in order that students may then solve real problems. Instead, it is the case, Krashen says, that learning is the result of working on real problems.
Writing that synthesizes knowledge gained from various sources, incorporates personal insights, and presents these in a structured way is an excellent example of a problem-solving activity that leads to cognitive development.
[More]
Writing
Krashen's (1984) early work in this field draws the distinction between writing competence and writing performance. Competence is the largely sub-conscious, abstract knowledge of what constitutes good prose. Competence is acquired for the most part through reading.§§ Performance, on the other hand, refers to the conscious application of strategies or rules that have been learned and practised. The distinction between competence and performance in writing parallels that between acquisition and learning in second language development.
In his later work Krashen (2003) investigates how writing can contribute to cognitive development. He summarizes research that shows how various writing activities, in particular note-taking and summary writing, are significant aids to learning §§.
[More]
An introduction to the work of Stephen Krashen
See also:
Jay Doubleyou: questioning and problem-solving
Jay Doubleyou: task-based learning
Jay Doubleyou: play and learning
Jay Doubleyou: processes and procedures
Jay Doubleyou: thinking fast and slow
Jay Doubleyou: the trivium method of critical thinking and creative problem solving
Jay Doubleyou: appreciative inquiry is not problem-solving
Jay Doubleyou: critical thinking
.
.
.
Saturday, 17 August 2019
othering
If you are 'exceptional', then everyone else is not:
Jay Doubleyou: exceptionalism today
And that leads to the idea of 'the other':
Other (philosophy) - Wikipedia
And the problem of 'othering':
The Problem of Othering: Towards Inclusiveness and Belonging
Jay Doubleyou: exceptionalism today
And that leads to the idea of 'the other':
Other (philosophy) - Wikipedia
And the problem of 'othering':
The Problem of Othering: Towards Inclusiveness and Belonging
john a. powell and Stephen Menendian
The problem of the twenty-first century is the problem of “othering.” In a world beset by seemingly intractable and overwhelming challenges, virtually every global, national, and regional conflict is wrapped within or organized around one or more dimension of group-based difference. Othering undergirds territorial disputes, sectarian violence, military conflict, the spread of disease, hunger and food insecurity, and even climate change.1
In a remarkably candid and wide-ranging recently published interview, US president Barack Obama cited tribalism and atavism as a source of much conflict in the world.2 In his view, many of the stresses of globalization, the “collision of cultures brought on by the Internet and social media,” and “scarcities,” some of which will be exacerbated by climate change and population growth, lead to a “default position” to organize by “tribe—us/them, a hostility toward the unfamiliar or unknown,” and to “push back against those who are different.”
The Problem of Othering: Towards Inclusiveness and Belonging - Othering and Belonging
And from the Guardian:
Us vs them: the sinister techniques of ‘Othering’ – and how to avoid them
The problem of the twenty-first century is the problem of “othering.” In a world beset by seemingly intractable and overwhelming challenges, virtually every global, national, and regional conflict is wrapped within or organized around one or more dimension of group-based difference. Othering undergirds territorial disputes, sectarian violence, military conflict, the spread of disease, hunger and food insecurity, and even climate change.1
In a remarkably candid and wide-ranging recently published interview, US president Barack Obama cited tribalism and atavism as a source of much conflict in the world.2 In his view, many of the stresses of globalization, the “collision of cultures brought on by the Internet and social media,” and “scarcities,” some of which will be exacerbated by climate change and population growth, lead to a “default position” to organize by “tribe—us/them, a hostility toward the unfamiliar or unknown,” and to “push back against those who are different.”
The Problem of Othering: Towards Inclusiveness and Belonging - Othering and Belonging
And from the Guardian:
Us vs them: the sinister techniques of ‘Othering’ – and how to avoid them
john a powell
Rapid social change causes all humans anxiety – but our response to this need not be negative, despite the best efforts of our politicians and media
Wed 8 Nov 2017
Rapid social change causes all humans anxiety – but our response to this need not be negative, despite the best efforts of our politicians and media
Wed 8 Nov 2017
The audience at US president Donald Trump’s speech to the National Rifle Association in Atlanta last April. Photograph: Jonathan Ernst/Reuters
We are in the midst of a rapidly changing world. More than 300 million people are currently living outside their homelands. Ethno-nationalism is on the rise – from the Rohingya peopleforced out of Myanmar in what many are calling the world’s latest genocide, to neo-Nazis marching through the streets of Charlottesville, Virginia, in an action President Trump pointedly refused to condemn.
Humans can only process a limited amount of change in a short period of time without experiencing anxiety. It’s a natural human reaction – but how we respond to that anxiety is social.
Othering is largely driven by politicians and the media, as opposed to personal contact
When societies experience big and rapid change, a frequent response is for people to narrowly define who qualifies as a full member of society – a process I call “Othering”. An alternative response is seeing the change in demographics as positive, and regarding the apparent other as enhancing our life and who we are. This is what I refer to as “belonging and bridging”.
Othering is not about liking or disliking someone. It is based on the conscious or unconscious assumption that a certain identified group poses a threat to the favoured group. It is largely driven by politicians and the media, as opposed to personal contact. Overwhelmingly, people don’t “know” those that they are Othering.
Us vs them: the sinister techniques of ‘Othering’ – and how to avoid them | Inequality | The Guardian
Here he is speaking:
john powell keynote: The Mechanisms of Othering - YouTube
And the idea of otherness from other writers and thinkers:
Consequences of Othering: Aladdin: Looking Deeper
The ‘othering’ of humanity, a divided world and the global rise in terrorism – Middle East Monitor
For example:
Furthermore, experiments such as the Brown Eyes, Blue Eyes exercise demonstrate just how readily we can be swept up in a group identity, learning to embrace only those of our tribe and reject the “others”, even when the difference is entirely arbitrary and meaningless.
Othering 101: What Is “Othering”? | There Are No Others
See:
Jay Doubleyou: jane elliott - brown eyes vs blue eyes
.
.
.
We are in the midst of a rapidly changing world. More than 300 million people are currently living outside their homelands. Ethno-nationalism is on the rise – from the Rohingya peopleforced out of Myanmar in what many are calling the world’s latest genocide, to neo-Nazis marching through the streets of Charlottesville, Virginia, in an action President Trump pointedly refused to condemn.
Humans can only process a limited amount of change in a short period of time without experiencing anxiety. It’s a natural human reaction – but how we respond to that anxiety is social.
Othering is largely driven by politicians and the media, as opposed to personal contact
When societies experience big and rapid change, a frequent response is for people to narrowly define who qualifies as a full member of society – a process I call “Othering”. An alternative response is seeing the change in demographics as positive, and regarding the apparent other as enhancing our life and who we are. This is what I refer to as “belonging and bridging”.
Othering is not about liking or disliking someone. It is based on the conscious or unconscious assumption that a certain identified group poses a threat to the favoured group. It is largely driven by politicians and the media, as opposed to personal contact. Overwhelmingly, people don’t “know” those that they are Othering.
Us vs them: the sinister techniques of ‘Othering’ – and how to avoid them | Inequality | The Guardian
Here he is speaking:
john powell keynote: The Mechanisms of Othering - YouTube
And the idea of otherness from other writers and thinkers:
Consequences of Othering: Aladdin: Looking Deeper
The ‘othering’ of humanity, a divided world and the global rise in terrorism – Middle East Monitor
For example:
Furthermore, experiments such as the Brown Eyes, Blue Eyes exercise demonstrate just how readily we can be swept up in a group identity, learning to embrace only those of our tribe and reject the “others”, even when the difference is entirely arbitrary and meaningless.
Othering 101: What Is “Othering”? | There Are No Others
See:
Jay Doubleyou: jane elliott - brown eyes vs blue eyes
.
.
.
exceptionalism today
Sure, we are all different, but are we also 'exceptional'?
EXCEPTIONAL | meaning in the Cambridge English Dictionary
There is then the concept of 'exceptionalism':
... the idea that a person, country or political system can be allowed to be different from, and perhaps better than, others:
EXCEPTIONALISM | meaning in the Cambridge English Dictionary
... the perception or belief that a species, country, society, institution, movement, individual, or time period is "exceptional" (i.e., unusual or extraordinary)
Exceptionalism - Wikipedia
And it's not just a European thing:
Thai exceptionalism - a myth or reality? - Thailand Visa Forum | The Nation
Chinese exceptionalism, law vs etiquette and ‘chopsticks people’ | South China Morning Post
And it's getting quite dangerous:
Modi and Indian exceptionalism
The National Identity XXIX: Stop Perpetuating the Myth of Kashmiri Exceptionalism
However, it's normally associated with the West - as covered before in this blog:
Jay Doubleyou: is the west better than the rest?
And in particular the United States:
American exceptionalism - Wikipedia
Here's a recent critique:
American Exceptionalism Is a Dangerous Myth
And here's an interview from last month with Noam Chomsky which looks at where the idea comes from:
Another recurring theme of U.S. history involves religious fundamentalism, which is still widespread throughout the country. Does the United States, in some ways, look more like a fundamentalist nation rather than an advanced secular republic?
Throughout its history the U.S. has been an unusually fundamentalist society, with regular Great Awakenings and beliefs that are far off the spectrum of developed societies. Almost 80 percent of Americans believe in miracles. There is a huge Evangelical community, a large part of Trump’s base, which he keeps in line by throwing them crumbs. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, a devout Evangelical Christian, speculated recently that God might have sent Trump to save Israel from Iran — which is threatening Israel with destruction in the fantasy world of doctrinal verities. Fully 40 percent of Americans expect Jesus to return to earth by mid-century (23 percent certainly). It’s possible that this accounts for some of the “looking away” that we were discussing earlier. All in all, it is a curious form of exceptionalism that goes back to the earliest settlers.
Noam Chomsky: To Make the US a Democracy, the Constitution Itself Must Change
Meanwhile in Britain - again, as covered before in this blog:
Jay Doubleyou: brexit: and what the british think of themselves
Jay Doubleyou: the problem with the english: england doesn’t want to be just another member of a team
Yes, the idea of 'exceptionalism' provides a very good way to understand Brexit:
The Imperial Myths Driving Brexit
Britain alternately believes it has been a towering empire and a plucky underdog, narratives that distract from real issues in its decision-making process.
At a time when both sides of the Brexit divide are invoking memories of the Second World War, historian Keith Lowe examines the realities of Britain’s role during the 1939–45 conflict, considering just how isolated its struggle was…
EXCEPTIONAL | meaning in the Cambridge English Dictionary
There is then the concept of 'exceptionalism':
... the idea that a person, country or political system can be allowed to be different from, and perhaps better than, others:
EXCEPTIONALISM | meaning in the Cambridge English Dictionary
... the perception or belief that a species, country, society, institution, movement, individual, or time period is "exceptional" (i.e., unusual or extraordinary)
Exceptionalism - Wikipedia
And it's not just a European thing:
Thai exceptionalism - a myth or reality? - Thailand Visa Forum | The Nation
Chinese exceptionalism, law vs etiquette and ‘chopsticks people’ | South China Morning Post
And it's getting quite dangerous:
Modi and Indian exceptionalism
The National Identity XXIX: Stop Perpetuating the Myth of Kashmiri Exceptionalism
However, it's normally associated with the West - as covered before in this blog:
Jay Doubleyou: is the west better than the rest?
And in particular the United States:
American exceptionalism - Wikipedia
Here's a recent critique:
American Exceptionalism Is a Dangerous Myth
And here's an interview from last month with Noam Chomsky which looks at where the idea comes from:
Another recurring theme of U.S. history involves religious fundamentalism, which is still widespread throughout the country. Does the United States, in some ways, look more like a fundamentalist nation rather than an advanced secular republic?
Throughout its history the U.S. has been an unusually fundamentalist society, with regular Great Awakenings and beliefs that are far off the spectrum of developed societies. Almost 80 percent of Americans believe in miracles. There is a huge Evangelical community, a large part of Trump’s base, which he keeps in line by throwing them crumbs. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, a devout Evangelical Christian, speculated recently that God might have sent Trump to save Israel from Iran — which is threatening Israel with destruction in the fantasy world of doctrinal verities. Fully 40 percent of Americans expect Jesus to return to earth by mid-century (23 percent certainly). It’s possible that this accounts for some of the “looking away” that we were discussing earlier. All in all, it is a curious form of exceptionalism that goes back to the earliest settlers.
Noam Chomsky: To Make the US a Democracy, the Constitution Itself Must Change
Meanwhile in Britain - again, as covered before in this blog:
Jay Doubleyou: brexit: and what the british think of themselves
Jay Doubleyou: the problem with the english: england doesn’t want to be just another member of a team
Yes, the idea of 'exceptionalism' provides a very good way to understand Brexit:
The Imperial Myths Driving Brexit
Britain alternately believes it has been a towering empire and a plucky underdog, narratives that distract from real issues in its decision-making process.
AUG 12, 2019
For more than three years, the world has watched Britain attempt to act on the result of its 2016 referendum and leave the European Union. Yet while the causes of the Brexit vote were complex, the causes of the catastrophic handling of the Brexit process might be familiar to anyone versed in imperial and postimperial history.
They stem from what appears to be a belief in British exceptionalism: the idea that Britain is inherently different from, and superior to, other nations and empires.
Margaret Thatcher asserted British exceptionalism with regard to the EU in a 1988 speech, and each of the past three prime ministers has approached the EU from that standpoint—believing that Britain deserves preferential treatment and more-than-equal status.
They have all also believed in their own personal exceptionalism. David Cameron believed he could win the referendum and thereby head off the electoral threat to his party from the right. He did not. Theresa May believed she could turn a narrow 52–48 vote in favor of leaving into a mandate for a “hard Brexit” in which Britain got everything it wanted and gave up nothing. She did not. Now Boris Johnson is voluntarily manufacturing a crisis over no deal—in which Britain would leave the EU without any agreement on the rules and regulations governing how it would trade and work with the bloc—that could send damaging shock waves through Britain, Ireland, and the rest of the EU.
There has been much discussion of the roles of history and memory in relation to Brexit. It may be easy to overstate a simplistic, literalist connection between the empire—imagined as glorious, and unjustly lost—and the impulse to leave the EU. Yet it is hard to avoid the sense that embedded in Brexit is a form of “Make Britain great again.” Sharper parallels are perhaps drawn between Britain’s collective recollection of its part in World War II, heavily mythologized as the moment it stood alone against Adolf Hitler, and the attitude of Brexit supporters to the isolation and hardship Brexit may bring.
While the myths constructed around the history of empire and World War II reinforce British exceptionalism, they are contradictory. The first casts Britain as a superpower; the second as a lone, plucky underdog...
For more than three years, the world has watched Britain attempt to act on the result of its 2016 referendum and leave the European Union. Yet while the causes of the Brexit vote were complex, the causes of the catastrophic handling of the Brexit process might be familiar to anyone versed in imperial and postimperial history.
They stem from what appears to be a belief in British exceptionalism: the idea that Britain is inherently different from, and superior to, other nations and empires.
Margaret Thatcher asserted British exceptionalism with regard to the EU in a 1988 speech, and each of the past three prime ministers has approached the EU from that standpoint—believing that Britain deserves preferential treatment and more-than-equal status.
They have all also believed in their own personal exceptionalism. David Cameron believed he could win the referendum and thereby head off the electoral threat to his party from the right. He did not. Theresa May believed she could turn a narrow 52–48 vote in favor of leaving into a mandate for a “hard Brexit” in which Britain got everything it wanted and gave up nothing. She did not. Now Boris Johnson is voluntarily manufacturing a crisis over no deal—in which Britain would leave the EU without any agreement on the rules and regulations governing how it would trade and work with the bloc—that could send damaging shock waves through Britain, Ireland, and the rest of the EU.
There has been much discussion of the roles of history and memory in relation to Brexit. It may be easy to overstate a simplistic, literalist connection between the empire—imagined as glorious, and unjustly lost—and the impulse to leave the EU. Yet it is hard to avoid the sense that embedded in Brexit is a form of “Make Britain great again.” Sharper parallels are perhaps drawn between Britain’s collective recollection of its part in World War II, heavily mythologized as the moment it stood alone against Adolf Hitler, and the attitude of Brexit supporters to the isolation and hardship Brexit may bring.
While the myths constructed around the history of empire and World War II reinforce British exceptionalism, they are contradictory. The first casts Britain as a superpower; the second as a lone, plucky underdog...
The Imperial Myths Behind Brexit in Britain - The Atlantic
And one of the strongest myths is that 'Britain stood alone' during the last world war:
Brexit is not World War II – politicians should stop comparing them
Quite literally:
WW2: When Britain stood (not quite) alone
And one of the strongest myths is that 'Britain stood alone' during the last world war:
Brexit is not World War II – politicians should stop comparing them
Quite literally:
WW2: When Britain stood (not quite) alone
At a time when both sides of the Brexit divide are invoking memories of the Second World War, historian Keith Lowe examines the realities of Britain’s role during the 1939–45 conflict, considering just how isolated its struggle was…
So if the British did not stand alone at the beginning of the war, nor at the end, what about during the middle? When most people talk of Britain standing alone, they usually refer to a single year, between June 1940 and June 1941. So let’s examine that year in detail.
... the fighter pilots defending our shores were no more exclusively British than any other group of people. Britain’s most successful squadron during the Battle of Britain was the Polish 303 Squadron, without whom, according to the head of Fighter Command, Sir Hugh Dowding, “I hesitate to say that the outcome of the battle would have been the same.” Some of our most successful fighter aces at this time were from Czechoslovakia (Josef František), Ireland (Paddy Finucane), South Africa (Adolph Malan) and New Zealand (Colin Gray and Brian Carbury). Pilots from 15 other nations fought during that famous summer. Together they constituted 20% of Fighter Command.
Thursday, 15 August 2019
the state of crime 2019
We've always been fascinated in crime - especially the more bloody and gruesome:
Jay Doubleyou: film noir
Jay Doubleyou: why are we so obsessed with murder?
But 'crime' is also a very political thing:
Social Conservatives’ Obsession with Crime | how to save the world
For example, how you feel about punishment... or about foreigners committing more crime:
Jay Doubleyou: crime and punishment
Or about crime being on the increase - although that's actually 'white collar' crime:
Jay Doubleyou: crime statistics - and the perception of crime
Or how you feel about human nature - and whether we are 'naturally' prone to crime:
Jay Doubleyou: a history of violence: another look at how violent we are
Jay Doubleyou: a history of violence part two
Or whether you feel the police are actually useful, or not:
Jay Doubleyou: debate: why do we need the police?
This is all part of a bigger picture of course:
Jay Doubleyou: culture wars
.
.
.
debate: why do we need the police?
More police does not mean less crime - and yet 'fears of rising crime and shrinking officer counts have emerged as common concerns' almost everywhere:
More cops. Is it the answer to fighting crime?
Simone Weichselbaum and Wendi C. Thomas The Marshall Project
Published 9:00 AM EST Feb 13, 2019
Responding to public panic over urban violence during the 1990s, President Bill Clinton signed off on millions of dollars in federal funds to hire thousands of local cops across the country. In 1997, two years after the money started to trickle out of Washington, the nation had 242 police officers for every 100,000 residents. By 2016, that number had dropped to 217 as law enforcement agencies shed jobs in the aftermath of a national recession while the nation’s population grew.
The national violent crime rate, over those 19 years, dropped by 37 percent. According to FBI data, in 1997 the national violent crime rate was 611.0 per 100,000 inhabitants. In 2016 the violent crime rate was 386.3 out of 100,000 inhabitants.
Fears of rising crime and shrinking officer counts have emerged as common concerns in cities across the nation from Dallas to Detroit to Memphis and elsewhere. Adding more cops to a violent city seems like an obvious fix, but there is conflicting research on the question of whether more cops drive down crime rates.
James McCabe, a retired New York Police Department official who travels the country as a police staffing consultant, says there is little clear connection between staffing numbers and crime. “New York City made the conscious decision to reduce the number of cops,” he noted in an interview. “And crime continued to go down. It’s not what you have, it’s what you are doing with them.”
More cops don't mean less crime, law enforcement experts say
Does Adding Police Reduce Crime? In Chicago, It's Complicated
October 19, 2016
Professor Wesley Skogan has studied police in Chicago for over 30 years and says the department's "traditional culture" needs a change.
Does Adding Police Officers Reduce Crime? (VIDEO)
What are 'Proactive Policing Strategies'? And are they effective in reducing crime?
Proactive Policing: Effects on Crime and Communities
Proactive-Policing
Are Proactive Policing Strategies Effective in Reducing Crime? - YouTube
Here's a little propaganda from Russia Today:
[111] Here's Why We Don't Need Police AT ALL w/ Alex Vitale - YouTube
But there might be a point...
And in the States, racial politics and gun politics are never far away:
Jay Doubleyou: gun culture
Jay Doubleyou: gun and violence issues
And in the States it's about the 'right to bear arms' - or, the right to defend yourself:
Negroes With Guns: Robert F. Williams on Self-Defense - YouTube
BANNING GUNS FOR NEGROES! Pt 1 THE RACIST ROOTS OF GUN CONTROL! - YouTube
Here's a little history:
Fear of a Black Gun Owner - The NRA Supported Gun Control When The Black Panthers Started Packing
By: Edward Wyckoff Williams
(The Root) -- It may seem hard to believe, but the modern-day gun-rights debate was born from the civil rights era and inspired by the Black Panthers. Equally surprising is that the National Rifle Association -- now an aggressive lobbying arm for gun manufacturers -- actually once supported, and helped write, federal gun-control laws.
It is ironic that the modern-day argument for citizens to arm themselves against unwarranted government oppression -- dominated, as it is, by angry white men -- has its roots in the foundation of the 1960s Black Panther movement. Huey Newton and Bobby Seale became inspired by Malcolm X's admonishment that because government was "either unable or unwilling to protect the lives and property" of African Americans, they ought to defend themselves "by any means necessary."
The Panthers responded to racial violence by patrolling black neighborhoods brandishing guns -- in an effort to police the police. The fear of black people with firearms sent shockwaves across white communities, and conservative lawmakers immediately responded with gun-control legislation.
Then Gov. Ronald Reagan, now lauded as the patron saint of modern conservatism, told reporters in California that he saw "no reason why on the street today a citizen should be carrying loaded weapons." Reagan claimed that the Mulford Act, as it became known, "would work no hardship on the honest citizen." The NRA actually helped craft similar legislation in states across the country. Fast-forward to 2013, and it is a white-male dominated NRA, largely made up of Southern conservatives and gun owners from the Midwest and Southwestern states, that argues "do not tread on me" in the gun debate.
Fear of a Black Gun Owner - The NRA Supported Gun Control When The Black Panthers Started Packing - Democratic Underground
Because, back in the 1960s, the question arose of Who polices the police?
.
The racist history of gun control in the US explained - YouTube
The Ku Klux Klan, Ronald Reagan, and, for most of its history, the NRA all worked to control guns. The Founding Fathers? They required gun ownership—and regulated it. And no group has more fiercely advocated the right to bear loaded weapons in public than the Black Panthers—the true pioneers of the modern pro-gun movement. In the battle over gun rights in America, both sides have distorted history and the law, and there’s no resolution in sight.
The Secret History of Guns - Adam Winkler - The Atlantic
Then there is the question of why today do we need the police if owning a gun is the best way to protect yourself?
Do We Need the Police? - YouTube
We police have become great protectors, but forgot how to serve | Melvin Russell | TEDxMidAtlantic - YouTube
To finish: the basic theory supporting strict policing - that is, the need for police:
broken windows theory - YouTube
.
.
.
More cops. Is it the answer to fighting crime?
Simone Weichselbaum and Wendi C. Thomas The Marshall Project
Published 9:00 AM EST Feb 13, 2019
Responding to public panic over urban violence during the 1990s, President Bill Clinton signed off on millions of dollars in federal funds to hire thousands of local cops across the country. In 1997, two years after the money started to trickle out of Washington, the nation had 242 police officers for every 100,000 residents. By 2016, that number had dropped to 217 as law enforcement agencies shed jobs in the aftermath of a national recession while the nation’s population grew.
The national violent crime rate, over those 19 years, dropped by 37 percent. According to FBI data, in 1997 the national violent crime rate was 611.0 per 100,000 inhabitants. In 2016 the violent crime rate was 386.3 out of 100,000 inhabitants.
Fears of rising crime and shrinking officer counts have emerged as common concerns in cities across the nation from Dallas to Detroit to Memphis and elsewhere. Adding more cops to a violent city seems like an obvious fix, but there is conflicting research on the question of whether more cops drive down crime rates.
James McCabe, a retired New York Police Department official who travels the country as a police staffing consultant, says there is little clear connection between staffing numbers and crime. “New York City made the conscious decision to reduce the number of cops,” he noted in an interview. “And crime continued to go down. It’s not what you have, it’s what you are doing with them.”
More cops don't mean less crime, law enforcement experts say
Does Adding Police Reduce Crime? In Chicago, It's Complicated
October 19, 2016
Professor Wesley Skogan has studied police in Chicago for over 30 years and says the department's "traditional culture" needs a change.
Does Adding Police Officers Reduce Crime? (VIDEO)
What are 'Proactive Policing Strategies'? And are they effective in reducing crime?
Proactive Policing: Effects on Crime and Communities
Proactive-Policing
Are Proactive Policing Strategies Effective in Reducing Crime? - YouTube
Here's a little propaganda from Russia Today:
[111] Here's Why We Don't Need Police AT ALL w/ Alex Vitale - YouTube
But there might be a point...
And in the States, racial politics and gun politics are never far away:
Jay Doubleyou: gun culture
Jay Doubleyou: gun and violence issues
And in the States it's about the 'right to bear arms' - or, the right to defend yourself:
Negroes With Guns: Robert F. Williams on Self-Defense - YouTube
BANNING GUNS FOR NEGROES! Pt 1 THE RACIST ROOTS OF GUN CONTROL! - YouTube
Here's a little history:
Fear of a Black Gun Owner - The NRA Supported Gun Control When The Black Panthers Started Packing
By: Edward Wyckoff Williams
(The Root) -- It may seem hard to believe, but the modern-day gun-rights debate was born from the civil rights era and inspired by the Black Panthers. Equally surprising is that the National Rifle Association -- now an aggressive lobbying arm for gun manufacturers -- actually once supported, and helped write, federal gun-control laws.
It is ironic that the modern-day argument for citizens to arm themselves against unwarranted government oppression -- dominated, as it is, by angry white men -- has its roots in the foundation of the 1960s Black Panther movement. Huey Newton and Bobby Seale became inspired by Malcolm X's admonishment that because government was "either unable or unwilling to protect the lives and property" of African Americans, they ought to defend themselves "by any means necessary."
The Panthers responded to racial violence by patrolling black neighborhoods brandishing guns -- in an effort to police the police. The fear of black people with firearms sent shockwaves across white communities, and conservative lawmakers immediately responded with gun-control legislation.
Then Gov. Ronald Reagan, now lauded as the patron saint of modern conservatism, told reporters in California that he saw "no reason why on the street today a citizen should be carrying loaded weapons." Reagan claimed that the Mulford Act, as it became known, "would work no hardship on the honest citizen." The NRA actually helped craft similar legislation in states across the country. Fast-forward to 2013, and it is a white-male dominated NRA, largely made up of Southern conservatives and gun owners from the Midwest and Southwestern states, that argues "do not tread on me" in the gun debate.
Fear of a Black Gun Owner - The NRA Supported Gun Control When The Black Panthers Started Packing - Democratic Underground
Because, back in the 1960s, the question arose of Who polices the police?
.
The racist history of gun control in the US explained - YouTube
.
Black Panthers demonstrating at the California Statehouse in 1967, prompting the “Mulford Act” - YouTube
The Mulford Act | Yvonna Russell
Mulford Act - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The Secret History of Guns
The Mulford Act | Yvonna Russell
Mulford Act - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The Secret History of Guns
ADAM WINKLER JUL 24 2011, 8:20 PM ET
The Ku Klux Klan, Ronald Reagan, and, for most of its history, the NRA all worked to control guns. The Founding Fathers? They required gun ownership—and regulated it. And no group has more fiercely advocated the right to bear loaded weapons in public than the Black Panthers—the true pioneers of the modern pro-gun movement. In the battle over gun rights in America, both sides have distorted history and the law, and there’s no resolution in sight.
The Secret History of Guns - Adam Winkler - The Atlantic
Then there is the question of why today do we need the police if owning a gun is the best way to protect yourself?
Do We Need the Police? - YouTube
We police have become great protectors, but forgot how to serve | Melvin Russell | TEDxMidAtlantic - YouTube
To finish: the basic theory supporting strict policing - that is, the need for police:
broken windows theory - YouTube
.
.
.
english accents
There are lots of accents in the UK:
Regional accents of English - Wikipedia
One Woman, 17 British Accents - Anglophenia Ep 5 - YouTube
The English Language In 24 Accents - YouTube
Learn British accents and dialects – Cockney, RP, Northern, and more! - YouTube
But it't not just British accents:
Accents - BRITISH vs AMERICAN: English Accents Around the World - YouTube
Accents of English Around the World - YouTube
28 Different English Speaking Accents - YouTube
Here's a great place to go to look at and listen to accents:
Accents of English | The AngloTIC Project
.
.
.
Regional accents of English - Wikipedia
One Woman, 17 British Accents - Anglophenia Ep 5 - YouTube
The English Language In 24 Accents - YouTube
Learn British accents and dialects – Cockney, RP, Northern, and more! - YouTube
But it't not just British accents:
Accents - BRITISH vs AMERICAN: English Accents Around the World - YouTube
Accents of English Around the World - YouTube
28 Different English Speaking Accents - YouTube
Here's a great place to go to look at and listen to accents:
Accents of English
For teachers. If you want extra materials, including tests, please get in touch with me at pennock@uv.es
English Language V (These activities are designed for students of English Language V. However, if you are not a student at the Universitat de València, you can do all the exercises on this page)
Introduction to English Accents (download pdf)
English Language VI (These activities are designed for students of English Language VI. However, if you are not a student at the Universitat de València, you can do all the exercises on this page)
New England English: Kennedy’s inaugural address (download pdf to listen to audio)
.
.
.
Monday, 12 August 2019
connected speech
What do we mean by 'connected speech'?
Here's a helpful video:
(1) Connected Speech Practice | English Pronunciation Lesson - YouTube
Here are the elements explained:
5 Connected Speech Secrets for Fast Native English Pronunciation
And it can all be heard in pop songs:
Use pop songs to learn connected speech and sound more fluent in English | British Council
What's y' favourite?
Meanwhile, here's some dialogue: How much can you get?!
Friends' Video - Listening for Connected Speech (ESL)
Connected Speech Practice Dialogues (Pronunciation) ESL
Here's a lesson:
connected speech – Tim's Free English Lesson Plans
And here's a good website with lots of activities:
Helping students with connected speech | elt-resourceful
.
.
.
Here's a helpful video:
(1) Connected Speech Practice | English Pronunciation Lesson - YouTube
Here are the elements explained:
5 Connected Speech Secrets for Fast Native English Pronunciation
And it can all be heard in pop songs:
Use pop songs to learn connected speech and sound more fluent in English | British Council
What's y' favourite?
Meanwhile, here's some dialogue: How much can you get?!
Friends' Video - Listening for Connected Speech (ESL)
Connected Speech Practice Dialogues (Pronunciation) ESL
Here's a lesson:
connected speech – Tim's Free English Lesson Plans
And here's a good website with lots of activities:
Helping students with connected speech | elt-resourceful
.
.
.
brexit and the culture wars
How do you see Brexit?
Here it is from the viewpoint of a comedian:
Jay Doubleyou: brexit as a teabag
Jay Doubleyou: european jokes about the british
It is a matter of viewpoint:
Jay Doubleyou: brexit: and what the british think of themselves
Jay Doubleyou: how brexit is viewed on the continent
How about this?
Jay Doubleyou: big british asian summer
Mad Max anybody?
Jay Doubleyou: the language of brexit
It's a question of values:
The Brexit culture war in numbers – POLITICO
Listen to this:
BBC Radio 4 - The Briefing Room, Why Did People Vote Leave?
It's something to worry about:
Britain in the midst of a cultural war as Brexit alters cultural identities
With more articles here:
Is Brexit a culture war or a class war?
The overlooked dynamic at the heart of the Brexit “culture war” | Prospect Magazine
Here's an analysis from the Sun:
Brexit politics is a culture war that has turned opponents into enemies – The Sun
Although the Guardian would of course disagree:
Forget culture wars. Class is still the defining force shaping British lives | Kenan Malik | Opinion | The Guardian
.
.
.
Here it is from the viewpoint of a comedian:
Jay Doubleyou: brexit as a teabag
Jay Doubleyou: european jokes about the british
It is a matter of viewpoint:
Jay Doubleyou: brexit: and what the british think of themselves
Jay Doubleyou: how brexit is viewed on the continent
How about this?
Jay Doubleyou: big british asian summer
Mad Max anybody?
Jay Doubleyou: the language of brexit
It's a question of values:
The Brexit culture war in numbers – POLITICO
Listen to this:
BBC Radio 4 - The Briefing Room, Why Did People Vote Leave?
It's something to worry about:
Britain in the midst of a cultural war as Brexit alters cultural identities
With more articles here:
Is Brexit a culture war or a class war?
The overlooked dynamic at the heart of the Brexit “culture war” | Prospect Magazine
Here's an analysis from the Sun:
Brexit politics is a culture war that has turned opponents into enemies – The Sun
Although the Guardian would of course disagree:
Forget culture wars. Class is still the defining force shaping British lives | Kenan Malik | Opinion | The Guardian
.
.
.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)